February 2008: Manhattan Retail, Office and Industrial Market Report
New York Market Overview:
Manhattan office rents have peaked at $225/RSF, making New York the 3rd most expensive office market in the world and highest in the United States. The recent bad news for Wall Street may mean reduced office and retail rents in Manhattan as the banks and investment banks sublease or vacate space.New DevelopmentsNew York City's office market has gained on the world's two most expensive cities, London and Hong Kong. London vaulted over Hong Kong to become the world's priciest office market with rent for Class A hitting $265 per square foot. The peak rate in New York City's Midtown reached $225 per square foot. The next most expensive U.S. office markets were San Francisco, with a rate of $110 per square foot; Boston, with a rate of $90 per square foot; and Manhattan's Downtown, with a rate of $65 per square foot.Steven Witkoff, Developer, pulled bid to develop Pier 57, planning to spend an estimated $400 million on building a bridge to the High Line, a marina, a museum, and a gourmet banquet hall. Witkoff got caught in the Manhattan district attorney's investigation of a former chairman of the Hudson River Park Trust, James Ortenzio, who a former chairman of the New York Republican County Committee pleaded guilty to a felony tax violation and failure to make a financial disclosure. Bad news for Wall Street may mean good news for Manhattan's congested office markets. By late December, the major financial houses had lost more than $40 billion related to the sub prime mortgage crisis, which may force tens of thousands of people out of work in Midtown and Lower Manhattan. The possible resulting layoffs have led brokers to believe that Wall Street firms will try to sublease some of their unused trading floors. New office inventory couldn't come at a better time for the Manhattan market. Asking rents in Manhattan hit $62.91 in the third quarter, representing a new record. The jump of 37.2 percent from the year-ago quarter was the biggest annual increase ever recorded. |
![]()
![]()
|
Citigroup and Merrill Lynch announced plans to counter enormous losses tied to sub prime mortgage investments. Citigroup, just posted the biggest loss in its history, it received $12.5 billion from outside investors to help recover from an $18 billion write-down. The bank is expected to cut 4,000 positions, following 17,000 job cuts announced last spring. Merrill Lynch will raise $6.6 billion from three foreign investment funds.
Morgan Stanley, Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. and Credit Suisse Group are eliminating about 1,640 jobs as the worst U.S. housing market in 26 years slows economic growth and their profit outlook.
The New York State Appellate Division denied an appeal against the state's use of eminent domain for Forest City Ratner's Atlantic Yards project.
The state commission studying the city's proposed congestion pricing plan is most likely to approve an $8 charge on vehicles entering Manhattan below 60th Street on weekdays. The commission also opposes Bloomberg's proposal to charge vehicles for trips within the congestion zone. The estimated $500 million in annual revenue would be given to mass transit.
Hudson Yards. There are five proposals for Hudson Yards, two from the Extell Development Company and Brookfield Properties. These two bids have been looked upon favorably by the public and/or architectural critics. It is the other three that are reportedly the favorites. All three of them have in common high-profile tenants. Reportedly, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, which owns the Hudson Yards site, has already narrowed down to three bids from the Related Companies, Tishman Speyer and Durst/Vornado, and that the authority may try to merge them. More importantly, New York needs to find an anchor tenant before the shovels are in the ground.
Financial District Hotel developments. Mr. Chang's is building a 350-room Holiday Inn at 99 Washington Street to open in mid 2009 opening.
The hotel business in New York City continues to boom, as a market niche is widening for select-service hotels in mid-block locations. These properties think of brand offshoots such as Hilton Garden Inn or Holiday Inn Express fall between the budget and luxury categories, offering mid-priced beds, decent coffee and Wi-Fi access. Hotel developers such as the McSam Hotel Group, the Lam Group and Hersha Hospitality are piling on to build them, encouraged by a real estate market that is favorable to smaller, hotel buildings tucked away on side streets, especially in areas like Midtown South, Midtown West and Chelsea. Gary Wisinski, chief operating officer of McSam Hotel Group, said that his company has plans for several new select-service mid-block hotels.
With an influx of young people, Korea town has changed the character of the 32nd Street neighborhood, driving rents up and creating demand for trendy new hangouts. In 2000, rents at the Korea town residential building Herald Towers were around the mid-$30s per square foot; now they've reached the mid-$50s. Developer of the Herald Towers said retail rents in the towers had increased by 30 to 40 percent since last year.
Median sale prices in Queens fell 5.2 percent to $460,000 in the fourth quarter, down from $485,000 in last year's fourth quarter. A decline in median sales prices across the overall Long Island-Queens market. Prices dropped by 3.2 percent to $425,000 this quarter, compared to $439,000 in the fourth quarter last year. The numbers have fluctuated between stable and weak for the last few quarters.
City Point tower is being built at a site in Downtown Brooklyn. It could become Brooklyn's tallest building if it reaches its planned 65 stories. The 1.9 million square-foot tower will include about 500,000 square feet of retail space, 280 hotel rooms, along with 800 residential rental units and 360,000 square feet of office space.
The Federal Reserve made an emergency interest rate cut of .75 percent, the biggest single cut since October 1984 as a fear of a recession looms. Along with cutting the key overnight interest rate to 3.5 percent, the Fed also cut the discount rate 75 basis points to 4 percent.
United Nations is negotiating a lease at 380 Madison Avenue for 600,000 square feet to relocate up to 1,700 employees from the Secretariat Building while the tower and other buildings on the UN's East Side campus undergo a renovation to begin next year. The deal, which is huge by Manhattan leasing standards and will be the biggest transaction to be completed in the city so far this year, constitutes more than what the United Nations initially planned in order to house staff that will be displaced by the work.
Over the summer, the United Nations reached an agreement to occupy the Albano Building, a 187,000 square foot fully vacant office property near its East Side campus in which it plans to move 700 employees.
International law firm Crowell & Moring signed a lease for 100,000 square feet at Minskoff Equities' 590 Madison Avenue. Rents on some floors are reportedly $135-$165 per square foot. The firm is moving from its 60,000-square foot offices at Boston Properties' 153 East 53rd Street, the Citigroup Building.
Foreclosures in New York City fell by 13 percent in the fourth quarter. The total of 605 foreclosures, however, was still 71 percent higher than the final quarter of 2006. On Staten Island, new foreclosure auctions jumped 53 percent; the other boroughs saw drops of 10 to 30 percent. The neighborhood with the most foreclosures was in Queens: Jamaica, South Jamaica, Hollis and St. Albans had 23. Foreclosures in the city were up 71 percent.
A weakening of the U.S. dollar brought a record number of visitors to New York City last year. An estimated 46 million people visited the city in 2007, an increase of 5 percent. Foreign visitors increased by an estimated 8.5 million, a jump of 17 percent.
A feud between the state redevelopment corporation and its contractor, Bovis Lend Lease, has been resolved. The demolition of the former Deutsche Bank building at 130 Liberty Street is set to resume. The Lower Manhattan Development Corporation announced that it hired a new subcontractor, LVI Services Inc., to remove asbestos and other hazardous materials and demolish the structure.
At the City Council's finance committee hearing, members questioned the need for Madison Square Garden's $11.5 million annual tax break. The tax break was created in 1982 after the arena's then-owners threatened to move the Knicks and Rangers to New Jersey. Barry Watkins, Garden president, said talks of ending the tax break are premature, while plans are drawn for a new arena at Moynihan Station.
The Port Authority has completed excavations at the site of Larry Silverstein's planned Tower 4 at the World Trade Center, designed by architect Fumihiko Maki. The agency said the adjacent Tower 3 site will be ready by the middle of next month.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg prepares for next week's State of the City address. He is considering ending a 7 percent property tax cut and a $400 property tax rebate for homeowners, to help close the city's budget gap. The mayor has always billed that as something we will do when we can afford it, but it's not permanent.
Due to credit drying up and Wall Street banks lending less to real estate investors, recent deals have been financed by balance sheet lenders, including insurance companies, savings banks and commercial banks. Many high-profile lenders involved in Manhattan deals are foreign; including Irish, Scottish, and German banks. For the purchase of 1177 Sixth Avenue, $700 million was provided in financing. Deals continue to happen, the shift to on-balance sheet lenders might result in lower leverage and higher cost of capital.
After years of delays, developer Edward Minskoff is moving forward with plans for a 110,000-square-foot parcel in Long Island City that was once a strip club. Minskoff has completed plans for both an office building and a college dorm at 30-30 Northern Boulevard, which is near Queens Plaza at the intersection of 40th Avenue and 31st Street. His development company, Edward J. Minskoff Equities, first planned an office building after acquiring the property about three years ago. After no anchor tenant was found, Minskoff switched gears and planned for a college dorm at the parcel. Now, Minskoff has completed one plan for an 18-story, 650,000-square-foot Class A office building and another for a 1,600-room college dormitory with classrooms and administrative offices that could be 18 stories or taller.
Ogilvy & Mather, the international advertising and public relations agency, says it will move its headquarters to 636 11th Avenue, at 47th Street. The WPP Group-owned company leased the entire 11-story building, which will undergo an interior redesign. Ogilvy will vacate 600,000 square feet of noncontiguous at the Harry Macklowe-owned Worldwide Plaza, on Eighth Avenue and 50th Street, next year. Hakimian Organization and its partners Peykar Brothers Realty and Gorjian Properties leased the building.
Developer Mort Zuckerman's Boston Properties has signed its first tenant at a planned tower at Eighth Avenue and West 55th Street. Law firm Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher has reportedly taken over 200,000 square feet. Law firm, Proskauer Rose, is expected to take about 400,000 square feet.
After selling its stake in the World Trade Center in 2003, the Westfield Group is now a big driver behind Ground Zero's redevelopment, with a $1.45 billion partnership with the Port Authority to develop and operate about 500,000 square feet of stores and restaurants.
Manhattan Buildings sold
Vornado Realty Trust has purchased a stake in loans tied to four buildings, owned by developer Harry Macklowe, who has a $6.4 billion debt payment for seven Midtown Manhattan office buildings purchased a year ago due next month.A third of commercial deals in the first three weeks of January were done by international buyers.
Philips International Holding Corp. sold a seven-story office building at 155 Fifth Avenue for $38 million to the Eretz Group, a New York-based real estate investment firm. Philips International bought the 32,500-square foot building at 21st Street from the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism.
Northbrook Partners paid more than $300 million for nine Upper West Side and West Village buildings, including at least two rentals. The firm is owned by the Racolin family, which bought and built several city buildings throughout the 1930s and 1940s. The buildings include 98 Riverside Drive; 48-60 Seventh Avenue and shares of a recently converted condominium at 172 West 79th Street. Northbrook was founded by Maurice Mann, president of Mann Realty Associates.
The Moinian Group purchased a vacant lot at 553 11th Avenue for $24.5 million, next door to its 46-story, 478-unit Atelier condominium at 627 West 42nd Street.
The Glad Tidings Tabernacle Church at 325 West 33rd Street sold for $31 million. A 95,000-square-foot, 250-room hotel will replace the church. The buyer, PLC Partners, is building the 300-room Cambria Suites Brooklyn Bridge hotel. Demolition has reportedly begun at the church.
The Lam Group purchased a vacant building for $13.1 million at 49-53 Ann Street, and is planning a hotel. The four-story loft building is 15,500 square feet, but has a maximum build able area of 45,800 square feet. The Lam Group is owned by developer, a former partner of hotelier Sam Chang. Lam is building a 660-room Sheraton under at and the 150-room Four Points by Sheraton Soho Village, at 66 Charlton Street between Varick and Hudson Streets.
The sale of the Hotel Riverview at 113 Jane Street, on the Hudson River, closed for $27 million. Hoteliers Sean MacPherson and Eric Goode, the team behind the Bowery Hotel and the Maritime Hotel on West 16th Street, have submitted plans to restore and revamp the landmark Hotel Riverview to Community Board 2's business committee.
The Related Companies' partners, Twining Properties and Macfarlane Partners, at a stalled development site that takes up an entire block at 42nd Street and Tenth Avenue, have cashed out their shares in the project. Meanwhile, Goldman Sachs and MSD Capital, which became the firm's first outside investors, last month, are now equity partners on the project at 440 West 42nd Street. A 60-story high rise residential tower with over 600 luxury apartments was planned after the former Houseman and Fairbanks theaters were cleared in 2005. The project failed to receive a zoning bonus and tax breaks for a proposed Cirque du Soleil complex in the tower's base.
New York Buildings For Sale
GM building Sale. The sale for the GM building could be in doubt as buyers are scared away by the pending lawsuit from Sheldon Solow. Developer Harry Macklowe is trying to sell the General Motors Building to pay off massive debts that are soon due. People wait to see who might try to buy the 50-story tower. Sheldon Solow, Larry Silverstein, Vornado CEO Steven Roth, and Tishman Speyer CEO Jerry Speyer. Bidding is expected to begin at $3.5 billion, and the property might not even sell. A recapitalization could be all that happens in the end. A lawsuit by developer Sheldon Solow, which alleges that 2003 purchase of the General Motors Building was fraudulent, could complicate Macklowe's attempts to sell the building. A judge ruled earlier this month the case could move forward, surprising observers. "The judge's decision could put the brakes on any sale, or at a minimum change the economics," said Ross Moskowitz, a real estate partner at Stroock & Stroock & Lavan. "Unless there is a comfort level on the merits of the litigation with a meaningful indemnification, any prospective buyer and lender would have to think long and hard about moving forward with this purchase.RFR Realty is planning to sell 17 State Street, the 42-story, 570,000 square foot office tower. The building is hoping to attract to hedge funds, money management firms and Internet companies. There is little available. A high floor suite has an asking rent of $45 per square foot.
SL Green wants to sell 39-story Herald Square at 1250 Broadway for $350 million.
A 275,000-square foot office building at 180 Madison Avenue will sell for $150 million, or $540 per square foot, to Ronnie Hackett's Claret Group. Four years ago, Sitt Asset Management paid $91.5 million to buy the building from SL Green Realty Corp.
New York Office Leases:
- Total Manhattan Office Class A vacancies decreased from 11.86 million RSF to 11.36 million RSF.
- Total Manhattan Office Market vacancies decreased from 22.35 million RSF to 20.94 million RSF.
- Total Manhattan Office direct lease vacancy decreased from 19.17 million RSF to 17.92 million RSF.
- Manhattan Office Sublease vacancy decreased from 3.19 million RSF to 3.01 million RSF.
- Total Manhattan Office Market vacancies decreased from 22.35 million RSF to 20.94 million RSF.
- Total Midtown South Office vacancy decreased from 4.38 million RSF to 4.15 million RSF.
- Total Midtown Office vacancy decreased from 12.49 million RSF to 11.57 million RSF.
- Total Downtown Office vacancy decreased from 5.48 million RSF to 5.22 million RSF.
- Total vacant Office Sublease Space in Midtown Manhattan decreased from 2.11 million RSF to 1.93 million RSF.
- Total vacant Office Direct Space in Midtown Manhattan decreased from 10.38 million RSF to 9.64 million RSF.
- Total vacant Office Direct Space in Midtown South Manhattan increased from 4.11 million RSF to 3.85 million RSF.
- Midtown South Manhattan Sublease vacancies decreased from 0.27 million RSF to 0.3 million RSF.
- Total Downtown Manhattan Office Direct Lease Space decreased from 4.68 million RSF to 4.44 million RSF.
- Total Downtown Manhattan Office Sublease Vacancies decreased from 0.8 million RSF to 0.79 million RSF.
Manhattan Retail Leases:
- Total Available Manhattan Retail Space decreased from 1.06 million RSF to 1.05 million RSF.
- Midtown South Retail vacancies decreased from 0.77 million RSF to 0.73 million RSF.
- Midtown vacancy increased from 0.21 million RSF to 0.23 million RSF.
- In Downtown, Retail vacancy increased from 0.08 million RSF to 0.09 million RSF
Manhattan Industrial Leases:
- Total Vacant Manhattan Industrial Space increased from 0.2 million RSF to 0.22 million RSF.
- Midtown South Industrial vacancies increased from 0.1 million RSF to 0.12 million RSF.
- Midtown vacancy stayed at 0.1 million RSF.
Manhattan Office Leases:
- Omnicom Group leases 183,768 RSF at 195 Broadway.
- Lord & Taylor leases 109,000 RSF at 601 West 26th Street.
- Sedgwick Detert Moran & Arnold LLP leases 75,446 RSF at 125 Broad Street.
- Latham & Watkins leases 70,000 RSF at 885 Third Avenue.
- Lester Schwab Katz & Dwyer LLP leases 60,000 RSF at 120 Broadway.
- American Eagle Outfitters leases 56,324 RSF at 417 Fifth Avenue.
- Venable LLP leases 52,000 RSF at 1270 Sixth Avenue.
- NYU Hospitals Center leases 44,995 RSF at 673 First Avenue.
- Hanesbrands Inc. leases 37,678 RSF at 16 East 34th Street.
- Leucadia National Corp. leases 32,000 RSF at 315 Park Ave South.
- Concept One Accessories leases 31,000 RSF at 119 West 40th Street.
- Iconix Brand Group leases 30,556 RSF at 1450 Broadway.
- Aeropostale Inc. leases 30,000 RSF at 112 West 34th Street.
- The Audubon Society leases 28,000 RSF at 225 Varick Street.
- Delco Apparel leases 26,000 RSF at 500 Seventh Avenue.
- Tory Burch leases 25,324 RSF at 11 West 19th Street.
- Kevin Ryan leases 21,500 RSF at 40 West 20th Street.
- Kohlberg Kravis Roberts leases 20,700 RSF at 730 Fifth Avenue.
- Enterprise Community Partners leases 20,200 RSF at One Whitehall Street.
- Staples leases 16,980 RSF at 16 East 34th Street.
- Phoenix Partners Group leases 16,400 RSF at 315 Park Ave South.
- Buro Happold leases 16,103 RSF at 100 Broadway.
- Sun Capital Advisors leases 10,750 RSF at 100 Park Avenue.
- BST Advisory Network leases 9,813 RSF at 28 West 44th Street.
- Olivet University leases 9,255 RSF at 6 Barclay Street.
- Exec/Comm leases 8,930 RSF at 28 West 44th Street.
- Cyruli Shanks Hart & Zizmor LLP leases 8,013 RSF at 420 Lexington Avenue.
- Visiting Nurse Service of New York leases 7,678 RSF at 1250 Broadway.
- Rosetti Handbags & Accessories Ltd. leases 7,117 RSF at 10 West 33rd Street.
- The Damon Runyon-Walter Winchell Foundation leases 7,000 RSF at 55 Broadway.
- Create-A-Marker leases 7,000 RSF at 254 West 35th Street.
- National Hockey League leases 6,781 RSF at 1185 Sixth Avenue.
New York City Retail Leases:
- American Eagle Outfitters leases 25,000 SF at 1551 Broadway.
- Gracious Home leases 24,300 SF at 55 West 25th Street.
- Prime 112 Steakhouse leases 12,000 SF at East 29th Street.
- JP Morgan Chase leases 5,482 SF at 2195 Frederick Douglass Blvd.
- JP Morgan Chase leases 5,024 SF at 775 Columbus Avenue.
- North Fork Bank leases 3,500 SF at 830 Ninth Avenue.
- North Fork Bank leases 3,000 SF at 144 Eighth Avenue.
- North Fork Bank leases 3,000 SF at 502 Park Avenue.
- Gotham Martial Arts leases 2,850 SF at 328 East 61st Street.
- AT&T leases 2,500 SF at 16 East Fordham Road.
- Detny Footwear leases 2,200 SF at 238 Mulberry Street.
- Five Guys Famous Burgers and Fries leases 2,200 SF at 496 LaGuardia Place.
- Cafe Blossom leases 2,000 SF at 466 Columbus Avenue.
- Starbucks leases 1,500 SF at 220 East 42nd Street.
- Dunkin Donuts leases 1,378 SF at 730 Columbus Avenue.
- Dunkin Donuts leases 1,201 SF at 606 10th Avenue.
- David’s Bagels leases 1,000 SF at 1034 Third Avenue.
- Dunkin Donuts leases 887 SF at 666 Fifth Avenue.
- Cohen’s Fashion Optical leases 550 SF at 1369 Third Avenue.
New York City Buildings Sold:
- 301 Park Avenue, 2 hotels, 2 adjacent lots, was sold to BH Hotels LLC for $1.400 billion.
- 120 Park Avenue, a 643,000 RSF office building, was sold to Global Holdings Inc. for $525 million.
- 31 West 52nd Street, a 30-story, 700,000 RSF office building, was sold to Paramount Group for $500 million.
- 250 West Street, a 11-story, 300,000 RSF office building, was sold to Coalco for $201 million.
- 2139 Broadway, a 212-unit apartment building, was sold to VII West 75th Street LLC for $109 million.
- 130 East 57th Street, a 17-story hotel, 200 room total, was sold to Eight Hospitality Ownership Inc. for $99 million.
- 915 Broadway, a 20-story, 207,304 RSF office building, was sold to Normandy Real Estate Partners.
- 641 Sixth Avenue, an 8-story, 149,885 mixed-use building, was sold to Atlas Capital Group for $85 million.
- 743 Fifth Avenue, a 10-story office building, was sold to Louis Vuitton for $60 million.
- 169 Columbia Heights, a 12 story, 74,393 SF residential building, was sold to Taurus Investment Holdings for $50 million.
- 1186 Broadway, a 12-story hotel, was sold to GFI Development Co.; Dune Real Estate Funds for $40 million.
- 548 West 22nd Street, a 4-story, 38,000 RSF commercial building, was sold to The Dia Art Foundation for $38 million.
- 27 Grand Street, a Development site, was sold to Extell Development for $33 million.
- 112 Ninth Avenue, a 4-story, 57,000 RSF apartment building, 65 units total, was sold to Fortuna Realty Group for $31 million.
- 415 Eighth Avenue, a Development site, was sold to Savanna Real Estate Fund for $27 million.
- 313 West 37th Street, an 8-story, 70,000 RSF office building, was sold to Charles Yassky for $26 million.
- 165 West 57th Street, a 5-story, 22,000 RSF commercial building, was sold to The Clover Foundation for $25 million.
- 138 William Street, a 7-story, 35,674 RSF commercial building, was sold to Swig Equities for $23 million.
- 204 West 14th Street, a 34,344 SF mixed-use building, was sold to a Westchester management company for $20 million.
- 1600 Sheepshead Bay Road, a Development site, was sold to Acadia Realty Trust for $20 million.
- 344 West 14th Street, a 6-story, 20,334 RSF apartment building, 25 units total, was sold to RE Equities Corp. for $14 million.
- 19-48 Hazen Street, a 2-story, 80,000 RSF industrial building, was sold to Safe Art Storage and Transport for $10 million.
Legend
RSF-Rentable Square FeetSF- Square Feet

